How @K_TyaJKT48 and co. Dominated Dareka no Tame ni 090914 19:00

Hello! Finally we're back to our original post of JKT48. This time, -Radit- had the honor of doing a review of Team J's Dareka no Tame ni setlist which features 5 Trainees from the 3rd generation. The five trainees are Sisca (2nd appearance), Tya, Manda, Shani, and Desy (all four had their 1st appearance today). Because of one thing and another, this show does not feature the three aces of team J and the top 3 of JKT48 (Melody, Haruka, and Veranda). Despite that, Team J should have no problem dominating the setlist because of their experience, right?

WRONG!

Having already watched how team J perform without their three aces on April 17th 2014, I already know what to expect. A very good Adyth and Shinkirou, but nothing else. I've blogged that review in "Why @veJKT48 is the true soul of Team J". Go ahead and read that if you're curious. For those who are tl;dr, here's the extract of that article:

For one thing, I expected the problem would be on Shinkirou and Koike. That wasn't the case though. The problem was on other songs, especially Warning, Seifuku ga Jama wo Suru, Natsu ga Ichatta.

For this particular show, Shinkirou was performed by Rica and Sendy who already have the 'chemistry', so this Shinkirou was beautiful in its own way. As for Koike, Sendy again became the Tsundere girl that she is and made the monologue so funny that I cannot stop laughing, so Adyth was not really an issue.

I noted from M01 that Dhike is not herself, kinda spaced out and not really engaged in the performance. So, this review may be a little harsh because team J was 3 member short because Jeje and Dena were also not feeling well.

The difference in this show and the April 17th show was the trainees. back then, Novinta, Saktia, Sisil, Shafa, and Dena were really just performing as substitutes and did not really try to outperform team J. Saktia had the potential as the spark of the performance, but she did not really try to burn the audience. As a result, the show was not really that satisfactory. It just didn't feel like they tried, or maybe they were just comfortable serving as backups. I don't know. It just did not feel as exciting as it should be

This time, however, the Trainees were more daring (or should I say, really impolite to team J hahaha) and they perform to the fullest. Maybe they realize that this was a great chance to show their seniors and the fans of their abilities. Several things to note

1. In the first article I mentioned about no one on the April 17th performance was able to replace the hole that Veranda left. In the 9-9 performance, Tya, assisted by Manda, was able to do that. She created 'the spark'. It's a different from Veranda's calm, but intense spark. Hers was very explosive and burning. Just like her Jikoshokai which implicates that she was the goddess of Fire. I would love to see her Duel Veranda who is the master of the wind (Miss Badai). In Warning, or in Tsuki no Katachi. hahaha

2. Desy and Sisca both showed their amazing MC skills. Granted their performance were not really that dazzling as Tya and Manda, but their MC were successful. I even read one of the audience's tweet about how the Trainee's MC (after Rider) were better than Team J's

3. Shani, the very "Jaga Image" girl. She was rather nervous in the first three song, but since Natsu ga Icchatta, she was on such a groove, performed beautifully, and eventually reached her peak in the very last song, Namida Uri No Shojou. Given this song is a little about 'galau' and sadness, she utilizes the skill she learned from her unit in Pajama Drive, Temodemo no Namida, which has similar feel to Namida Uri no Shojou.

4. All trainees seems to be full of energy while team J looks wasted. They did have a week full of nothing so that is kinda of an unfair advantage considering team J just got done with Pajama Drive Week. Also, Trainees were built to perform Pajama Drive which is, in my opinion, the most tiring setlist JKT48 has ever perform.

Even though the unit the trainee's perform is the easiest unit, still kudos to them because they have short time to learn the unit and the blocking for other songs. I mean, learning Tsukimisou and Warning is not exactly easy because everyone has its own moves and blocking. It's not like learning songs in Pajama Drive which some blocking has the same moves.

Overall, the trainees are quite good in performing Dareka no Tame ni. If there is one thing to be addressed is the fact that they have yet to embrace the true feel of Rider (the feel of losing someone important as opposed to the feel they perform today, the feeling of seeing someone left on a journey). If they can manage that, they may, no, they WILL outperform the original Riders.

To conclude, I am a little disappointed that they were all stacked up to Rider. Tya and Manda would do well in Bird and Shani would shine in Shinkirou. Maybe next time. Maybe Andela and Elaine would get a chance to perform. Also, I like how JOT selects members that suits well with the dark theme of Dareka no Tame ni.

As usual, you can leave a comment, rebuttal, argument down below or mention us Directly @Light_Unit or even directly to @Radityo_Utomo. Feel free to attack because this article is a direct sarcasm on how team J couldn't control their own setlist :)

-radit-